Engineer, teach thyself
Engineering clubs let students learn from their own quirky obsessions. Case in point: Waterloo's student-built solar car.
It travels faster than the speed limit on any Canadian highway, can drive coast-to-coast without stopping for gas, often gets mistaken for a UFO, and does all of this on less power than it takes to operate a toaster. It is the University of Waterloo’s solar-powered car, the Midnight Sun IX, a vehicle that can move at speeds of up to 115 km/h, from dawn until a few hours after dusk. Right now, this latest version is crated up and being transported to Australia, where later this fall it
will compete in the World Solar Challenge, a biannual 3,000-km race across the outback, and the premier competition of its kind. And while the solar car is an engineering wonder, what may be even more impressive is that the project is entirely powered by student volunteers.
From the person hoisting the vehicle to the mechanic under the hood, from the business management team squeezing CEO hands for donations to the project manager, each and every one is a Waterloo student. And
they aren’t even doing it for an academic credit: this isn’t a course, it’s a club. The only faculty member involved is the faculty adviser, and he just “makes sure that we aren’t breaking any policies, or doing something unsafe,” says Jessica Whitney, a 2007 civil engineering graduate and the business manager for Midnight Sun IX.
What’s most exceptional is that studentrun clubs like the Waterloo solar-car project are common at engineering schools across Canada. They are also wide-ranging. At the University of British Columbia, for instance, engineering students designed a car that makes Smart Cars look like gas-guzzling Hummers by comparison. Their Supermileage car can travel from Vancouver to Halifax on a gallon of gas, and was named one of
the 50 top inventions of2006 by Time magazine. On the other hand, over at the University of Alberta, the Autonomous Robotic Vehicle Project built a robot named “Ursa Minor” which, inspired by too many movies, is bent on world domination. Ursa ran for University of Alberta Student Union president this spring, but failed to win. “I am not sure this is the end of Ursa Minorafter all, it took three movies to destroy the Death Star,” says Michael Janz, winner of the election. Janz expects Ursa will only improve; the U of A already has a robot that is unbeatable at checkers.
At the University of Waterloo, all the members of the solar-car project have other commitments: part-time jobs, involvement in other student groups and the like. But, as with other engineering-club teams, the car club is special: members often get together in their office just to socialize and do schoolwork together. “It is more than just a team, it is like an extended family,” says Chris Jee,
a fourth-year electrical engineering student who is the team’s primary electrical manager. At the heart of the camaraderie, though, is the project: members spent thousands of hours together building the club’s ninth version of a solar car. Design work started in October 2005, with more than 400 students involved over two years and a core group of 15, before the car was unveiled on Aug. 12, 2007.
The Midnight Sun IX is 1.8 m wide, five metres long, and just less than one metre high (by comparison, a Toyota Prius hybrid is 1.72 m wide, 4-5 m long, and 1.5 m high). Most of the funding for developing it came from corporate donations and in-kind gifts. The project enjoys sponsorship from over 50 businesses, university departments, foundations and individuals. Gold level sponsors Advantage Engineering Inc., American Dicing Inc., Fleet Canada Inc., and Research In Motion each contributed over $25,000. The money was welcome: building the vehicle
and ancillary costs—such as transporting it to Australia—cost nearly $200,000.
Wayne Loucks, Waterloo’s associate dean for undergraduate studies in engineering, believes strongly that being part of one of the many teams offered in engineering benefits the students by bringing “more realism to the education experience.” The solar car team, “along with all the student projects, are important to the environment we provide to students,” he says. It’s not just the technical aspects that benefit students, but the chance to fundraise and manage the team that add to the student’s education. “In the real world, there is so much more than what can be taught in the classroom alone,” Loucks says. “The deadlines involved are more real: if you do not raise the funds you need in time, your project does not move forward. With classes, if you miss a deadline, the class continues, you lose the marks but things continue to move forward. In the real world, that does not happen.”
MORE INTERNATIONAL STUDENTS, BUT FEWER WOMEN After growing throughout the '90s, female enrolment at Canadian engineering schools began to fall after 2002. International student enrolment, in contrast, has risen sharply since the mid-1990s.
Source: Engineers Canada
A RISING TIDE: ENGINEERING ENROLMENT Full-time undergraduate enrolment in Canadian engineering programs has risen steadily since 2002. Approximately 10 per cent of Canada's full-time undergraduates are studying engineering.
Along with gaining real-life experience, there are other perks to being involved in projects such as the solar-car club. Although the team’s work is not part of the curriculum, students do sometimes find ways to integrate aspects from the project with courses (all Waterloo engineering students are required to complete a senior design project, and some, for instance, have been known to design widgets for the team, submit them for marks, and then install them in a vehicle). And then there is Oktoberfest, a major event in Kitchener/Waterloo, where the solar-car team is one of the participants in the parade (the vehicle is street legal, and licensed and registered in Ontario, but on the road is escorted by support vehicles for visibility and safety). In fact, the car is among the main attractions, and Whitney says “one of the great things about being on the team is how excited people get when they see the car.” Children especially like it, and both schools and day camp groups come to the university to see and learn about the vehicle.
Team members do not limit their education campaigns to Waterloo. In 2004, they set a world record for longest journey by a solar car by driving an earlier version of Midnight Sun 15,079 km over 41 days. That trip covered the United States and southern Canada, and was meant to educate people about
the potential of alternative fuels and solar energy. Most importantly, participants had the time of their lives, visiting places such as Vancouver, San Francisco, Houston, Florida, Washington, New York City and Halifax before
finally ending their journey on Parliament Hill. Their Guinness record hangs proudly in the team office. But the car was so unusual that it was often mistaken for something else. “When we drove across North America, people twice called into local radio stations to report a UFO on the highway,” says Whitney.
The team races every year against other engineering clubs from across North America, and every other year in the Australian world challenge. This year, other Canadian engineering schools taking part Down Under include the University of Calgary, Queens, Ecole Polytechnique de Montréal, the University of Toronto and the University of Western Ontario. Waterloo’s car will arrive in Australia in four weeks. It is currently in two components, the top with the solar panels, and the bottom, which includes the driver’s cage. Members are excited about the trip. When asked about the infamous stereotype
TWO OF THE MOST POPULAR COMPETITIONS: THE GREAT NORTHERN CONCRETE TOBOGGAN RACE AND THE CANADIAN CONCRETE CANOE CHAMPIONSHIPS
HOT, COMPUTER ENGINEERING IS NOT: WHAT STUDENTS ARE STUDYING
Of more than a dozen engineering disciplines, here are eight of the most popular. Electrical, mechanical and civil engineering continue to be mainstays, while computer engineering numbers have dropped by almost half in the past four years.
Discipline 2002 2006 Chemical 3,389 4,466 Civil..................................................... 4,917 8,088 Computer 8,127 4,380 Electrical 10,260 10,822 Engineering Physics 2,582 3,052 Industrial or Manufacturing 1,845 2,253 Mechanical 10,993 12,865 Software 1,001 1,995
Source: Engineers Canada
HOW HARD WILL IT BE TO GET IN?
Here are the average final-year grades—or the R score in the case of Quebec's CÉGEP system—of first-year undergrads starting engineering school in fall 2006.
Average Entering Grade Acadia 86.6% UBC 86.7% Carleton 83.6% Concordia 75.9% / R score 26.63 École de technologie Not Applicable supérieure Guelph 80.8% Laurentian 78%* Laval R score 28.02 McGill 87.8% / R score 29.63 McMaster 83.7% New Brunswick 84.7% UNBC 91.9% University of Ontario 76.4% Institute of Technology Ottawa 80.8%* École Polytechnique R score 29.13 de Montréal Québec à Montréal R score 27.65 Québec à Trois-Rivières R score 25.29 Queen's 87.6% Regina 82.2% Royal Military College 83% Ryerson 79% St. Francis Xavier 86.7% Saskatchewan 84% Toronto 86.8% Victoria 87% Waterloo 85.5% Western 84.7% Windsor 80%* York 84.7%
Seventeen universities with engineering programs are not listed here. These institutions did not release their average entering grades to Maclean's.
*Grade average for fall 2005 incoming class. (Source: Common University Data Ontario)
of engineering students as heavy drinkers, they said they do not consume any alcohol prior to or during the race. However, at the end they do enjoy an evening in Adelaide prior to packing up the car and returning to classes in Canada.
The Canadian teams often have some fun with each other, which includes attaching their faculty stickers to each others’ support vehicles and engaging in friendly verbal jousting. The University of Toronto’s infamous Brute Force Committee—a secretive group of U of T engineers who love to prank other schools—is especially known for this. Their trademark act: placing BFC stickers in difficult-to-reach places. Last year, they covered the McMaster engineering lounge with stickers (and placed a Trojan Horse in front of the building). This past summer, they scaled the entrance to the student centre at Mac and put a sticker on the clock above one of the main doorways. The BFC has also managed to get its sticker on past solar-car racers.
Solar cars and one-upmanship in pranks aside, there are many other engineering club competitions. Some of the most popular involve such things as building mini Baja racers, SAE formula racing cars, model aircraft, model cargo aircraft, autonomous search-and-rescue model aircraft, and two engineering challenges built around goofy Canadiana: the concrete toboggan and concrete canoe competitions. The challenge? Make a toboggan or canoe completely from concrete—and race it. It may seem impossible, but that’s the beauty of the challenge. Engineering teams work year-round formulating new mixtures of concrete to be lighter and more flexible.
The Great Northern Concrete Toboggan Race—last year’s event was held at the University of Manitoba—brings together engineering schools from across Canada. The sleds themselves must be constructed of a metal frame, with the running surface made entirely of concrete. They must have a working braking system, a roll bar to protect the five passengers, and weigh less than 300 lb. Last year’s winner: the Université de Sherbrooke’s “Pimp My Toboggan.”
Last May, the Canadian Concrete Canoe championships brought teams from nine universities and one college to Queen’s in Kingston, Ont., where they raced their patioslab, sidewalk-grade canoes. A concrete canoe sounds like an invention that just won’t float. Still, as one engineering student put it, the same could be said of ships made of steel, “but you do not see tankers crashing to the bottom of the sea—it’s all about water displacement.” This year’s Concrete Canoe champion was also the Université de Sherbrooke.
Out West, the University of Saskatchewan may be in a province known more for its wheat fields than innovative technology, but that has not stopped it from having one of the best space design teams in North America. During its 50th anniversary celebrations, NASA published a book in which it named USask’s Space Design Team one of the organizations that will have an impact
on the future of space exploration.
In both 2005 and 2006, the University of Saskatchewan won the NASA-sponsored Elevator: 2010 space elevator competition. The space elevator is a solar-powered lifting vehicle that operates on a wire to lift materials skyward. It is believed that, someday, a similar system could be implemented to lift large cargoes into space at a location near the equa-
ENGINEERING ENROLMENT, SCHOOL BY SCHOOL
Canada's engineering schools run from giant powerhouses offering a full range of engineering disciplines, such as Waterloo, Toronto and UBC, to smaller programs that have only recently been accredited by Engineers Canada, including UNBC, UOIT, UQAM and York.
Source: Engineers Canada
tor. USask’s team placed first in the climber competition, but just barely missed picking up the $150,000 prize money because their descent time was too slow. For the upcoming competition, the mark set by NASA is to have
a climber that can move up a 120-m-long vertical ribbon at a minimum speed of two metres per second. The team will attempt to achieve this in the Utah desert in October.
Some engineering teams design their cre-
ations just for fun, without any competitions. The McMaster University Engineering Society operates a carpool team. Most people think of a carpool as a group of commuters who share a vehicle to get to work. McMaster engineering students took the word literally— to mean, put a pool in a car. The engineers have an ’80s Chevy that has had the roof and interior removed and replaced with hot tub lining. Using the heat generated by the engine and electricity derived from piston movement, they turned the car into a moving hot tub on wheels. The driver and the passengers travel in the luxury of a warm body of water and are a fixture at local football games, where they pull the car into the end zone area to enjoy the action. The team has also been known to park in reserved carpool parking spots. When questioned, they point to the tub.
All such teams have one thing in common. Through hours of hard work, whether on the road or in the shop, members often spend many sleep-deprived hours together and form an incredible bond. All the teams encourage any student to join their ranks, including non-engineering students. “I can tell you from experience,” says Bruce of Waterloo, ■‘that these will be the best moments of your university career.” M